Anthony Jenkins

Menu

Everything homebuyers need to know about Oil Tanks

By /

1. What an Oil Tank Is (and Why Homes Have Them)

An oil tank stores heating oil for homes that use oil-fired furnaces or boilers. Oil is delivered periodically and burned to produce heat and hot water.

Oil-heated homes are most common in:

  • Older homes

  • Rural or suburban areas

  • Regions without natural gas service

2. Types of Oil Tanks

By Location

Above-Ground Tanks

  • Located in basements, garages, or outside

  • Easier to inspect, maintain, and replace

  • Lower environmental risk

  • Preferred by insurers and buyers

Underground Oil Tanks (USTs)

  • Buried in the yard or under the house

  • Harder to inspect

  • Higher risk of corrosion and leaks

  • Often a major red flag for buyers

By Material

  • Steel (most common)
    Lifespan: ~15–25 years
    Prone to corrosion over time

  • Fiberglass or Double-Wall Tanks
    Longer lifespan
    More expensive but safer

3. Why Oil Tanks Matter to Home Buyers

Financial Risk

A leaking oil tank can contaminate soil and groundwater.

  • Cleanup costs: $10,000–$100,000+

  • Homeowner is legally responsible—even if the leak happened years ago

Insurance Issues

  • Some insurers refuse coverage for homes with:

    • Underground tanks

    • Tanks older than a certain age (often 20–25 years)

  • You may need tank replacement before closing

Resale Impact

  • Underground tanks can:

    • Reduce home value

    • Scare off future buyers

    • Delay or kill a sale

4. How to Tell If a Home Has (or Had) an Oil Tank

Signs of an Active Tank

  • Oil fill pipe and vent outside the house

  • Oil gauge on the tank

  • Oil delivery records

  • Furnace or boiler labeled “oil”

Signs of a Buried or Abandoned Tank

  • Capped or cut pipes sticking out of the ground

  • Unexplained patches in the yard or driveway

  • Old permits or town records

  • Seller disclosures mentioning “removed” tanks

⚠️ Important: A “removed” tank doesn’t always mean the soil is clean.

5. Oil Tank Inspections (What Buyers Should Do)

Above-Ground Tank Inspection

Checks include:

  • Age and manufacturer

  • Rust, dents, or corrosion

  • Leaks or oil smells

  • Condition of supply lines and valves

Underground Tank Testing

Options:

  • Soil testing

  • Ground-penetrating radar (GPR)

  • Tightness testing (limited reliability)

  • Full tank removal (most definitive)

💡 Many buyers require tank removal with clean soil results before closing.

6. Oil Tank Removal: What to Know

Removal Options

  • Abandon in Place (not recommended)

    • Tank emptied and filled with sand or foam

    • Still may cause insurance or resale issues

  • Full Removal

    • Tank excavated and disposed of

    • Soil tested

    • Most buyer- and insurer-friendly option

Costs

  • Above-ground removal: $500–$1,500

  • Underground removal (no contamination): $2,000–$5,000

  • Cleanup with contamination: $10,000–$100,000+

7. Environmental & Legal Considerations

  • Homeowners are typically strictly liable for contamination

  • Even old, inactive leaks can trigger liability

  • Some states require reporting leaks to environmental agencies

  • Cleanup must meet state environmental standards

8. Insurance and Oil Tanks

Before buying:

  • Ask your insurer:

    • Will they insure the home with the current tank?

    • Are there age or location restrictions?

  • Some insurers require:

    • Tank under 20 years old

    • Proof of removal or soil testing

    • Replacement before coverage begins

9. Buying a Home With an Oil Tank: Smart Strategies

As a Buyer

  • Require oil tank inspection

  • Negotiate:

    • Seller removal

    • Cleanup escrow

    • Price reduction

  • Avoid assuming liability without documentation

As a Seller (If You’re Reading Ahead)

  • Remove underground tanks before listing

  • Provide clean soil certificates

  • Replace old above-ground tanks proactively

10. Alternatives to Oil Heating

Many buyers consider converting to:

  • Natural gas

  • Propane

  • Electric heat pumps

  • Geothermal systems

Conversion costs vary but can:

  • Eliminate oil tank risk

  • Improve resale value

  • Reduce long-term energy costs

Bottom Line for Home Buyers

Oil tanks aren’t automatically bad—but unknown, old, or underground tanks are serious risks. The smartest buyers:

  • Investigate early

  • Insist on documentation

  • Budget for removal or replacement

  • Never assume “no problem” without proof

If you want, I can also help with:

  • Questions to ask sellers

  • Sample inspection contingencies

  • State-specific oil tank laws

  • Deciding whether to walk away from a deal

For additional tips please visit the states website below

https://www.pa.gov/agencies/dep/residents/my-water/private-wells/tips-for-residential-heating-oil-tank-owners

Want to discuss more, complete form below

https://ajenkinshomes.com/contact/